The Full Horrifying Hot Sauce Lineup

Our sauces range from PG *mild* to NC-17 *crazy hot*

All of HHS' sauces are either fermented for a minimum of two weeks, or incorporate fresh ingredients with a fermented brine. Then at blending we usually add additional fresh ingredients to balance the fermented flavor.

Check out our currently available sauces in the store now.

Year-Round

  • What We Eat in the Shadows (5oz)

    What We Eat in the Shadows

    What We Eat in the Shadows blends red jalapeño, Barker's Extra Hot NM, and chocolate habanero peppers with brine, apple cider vinegar, and garlic prepared five ways, finished with a touch of brown sugar for a balanced heat. Perfect for fans of quirky horror and collectors seeking a flavorful, fun, and spooky addition to their pantry that goes great on everything.

    Hover for more…
    What We Eat in the Shadows blends red jalapeño, Barker's Extra Hot NM, and chocolate habanero peppers with brine, apple cider vinegar, and garlic prepared five ways, finished with a touch of brown sugar for a balanced heat. Perfect for fans of quirky horror and collectors seeking a flavorful, fun, and spooky addition to their pantry that goes great on everything.
    PG-13 Rated PG-13
  • The Burning (5oz)

    The Burning

    The Burning is inspired by the 1980 cult classic of the same name. This PG-13 sauce layers mango, pineapple, and an intense mix of red jalapeño, manzaño, habanero, and ghost peppers. Starting with sweet tropical notes, it quickly develops a deep, lingering heat for those who dare. Perfect on grilled dishes, wings, or bold culinary experiments.

    Hover for more…
    The Burning is inspired by the 1980 cult classic of the same name. This PG-13 sauce layers mango, pineapple, and an intense mix of red jalapeño, manzaño, habanero, and ghost peppers. Starting with sweet tropical notes, it quickly develops a deep, lingering heat for those who dare. Perfect on grilled dishes, wings, or bold culinary experiments.
    PG-13 Rated PG-13
  • MoMo (5oz)

    MoMo

    MoMo is a creepy, playful sauce inspired by the mysterious pairing of mango and manzano peppers — hence the name. With sweet, fruity mango notes, tangy vinegar, and a sneaky, lingering manzano heat, this small-batch sauce is perfect for daring flavor explorers. Use it on chicken, eggs, or anything that needs a tropical kick with a hint of menace. Hand-packed and carefully bottled, MoMo is a cult favorite for collectors seeking unusual, memorable flavor.

    Hover for more…
    MoMo is a creepy, playful sauce inspired by the mysterious pairing of mango and manzano peppers — hence the name. With sweet, fruity mango notes, tangy vinegar, and a sneaky, lingering manzano heat, this small-batch sauce is perfect for daring flavor explorers. Use it on chicken, eggs, or anything that needs a tropical kick with a hint of menace. Hand-packed and carefully bottled, MoMo is a cult favorite for collectors seeking unusual, memorable flavor.
    PG Rated PGIn stock
  • OMG!!!!!!! (5oz)

    OMG!!!!!!!

    OMG!!!!!!! is a whirlwind of jalapeño, serrano, manzaño, habanero, chayote, lemon, and tomatillo peppers, combined with fresh and black garlic, delivers a punchy, unpredictable heat inspired by the scary denizens of Nilbog. Sweetened with brown sugar and brightened with fermented lemons and a touch of lime juice, this year-round sauce is perfect for adventurous eaters looking for a taste that screams, “Ohhhhhhhh Myyyyyyyyyy Godddddddddd!!!” on tacos, nachos, or straight off the spoon.

    Hover for more…
    OMG!!!!!!! is a whirlwind of jalapeño, serrano, manzaño, habanero, chayote, lemon, and tomatillo peppers, combined with fresh and black garlic, delivers a punchy, unpredictable heat inspired by the scary denizens of Nilbog. Sweetened with brown sugar and brightened with fermented lemons and a touch of lime juice, this year-round sauce is perfect for adventurous eaters looking for a taste that screams, “Ohhhhhhhh Myyyyyyyyyy Godddddddddd!!!” on tacos, nachos, or straight off the spoon.
    PG Rated PG
  • Pazuzu (5oz)

    Pazuzu

    Pazuzu is a slow-building R-rated sauce that balances the fruity sweetness of watermelon and prickly pear with sweet-tart blueberries and punchy heat from Habanero, with some Ghost and Carolina Reaper peppers to make the heat linger. The combination teases the tongue before launching a fiery crescendo, making it a must-try for heat adventurers and horror enthusiasts alike. Plus, it's purple!

    Hover for more…
    Pazuzu is a slow-building R-rated sauce that balances the fruity sweetness of watermelon and prickly pear with sweet-tart blueberries and punchy heat from Habanero, with some Ghost and Carolina Reaper peppers to make the heat linger. The combination teases the tongue before launching a fiery crescendo, making it a must-try for heat adventurers and horror enthusiasts alike. Plus, it's purple!
    R Rated RIn stock
  • Shutteracha (5oz)

    Shutteracha

    Shutteracha is an Americanized take on classic Thai-style sriracha, blending red jalapeño, guajillo, red NM, manzaño, and habanero peppers. This PG-rated sauce balances heat with sweetness from agave and light brown sugar, finished with lime juice and rice wine vinegar. Perfect for wings, Asian-inspired dishes, or adventurous culinary creations, it’s a crowd-pleasing hot sauce with a supernatural edge.

    Hover for more…
    Shutteracha is an Americanized take on classic Thai-style sriracha, blending red jalapeño, guajillo, red NM, manzaño, and habanero peppers. This PG-rated sauce balances heat with sweetness from agave and light brown sugar, finished with lime juice and rice wine vinegar. Perfect for wings, Asian-inspired dishes, or adventurous culinary creations, it’s a crowd-pleasing hot sauce with a supernatural edge.
    PG Rated PG

Collaboration Sauces

  • All About Peaches (5oz Waxed)

    All About Peaches

    All About Peaches is the official hot sauce of Peaches Christ, created for the 3rd HORRIDfying Film Festival’s presentation of their film, All About Evil. This limited batch swaps out Buffet for Sheetar’s plums for peaches and raspberries for pink pineapple, with peppers dialed up to a dangerously fiery level. Perfect for fans or anyone craving a cinematic blast of heat, this sauce brings bold, fruity flavor to wings, pork, or even adventurous desserts. Hand-bottled and carefully packed, it’s a must-have for fans of indie horror and Peaches Christ.

    Hover for more…
    All About Peaches is the official hot sauce of Peaches Christ, created for the 3rd HORRIDfying Film Festival’s presentation of their film, All About Evil. This limited batch swaps out Buffet for Sheetar’s plums for peaches and raspberries for pink pineapple, with peppers dialed up to a dangerously fiery level. Perfect for fans or anyone craving a cinematic blast of heat, this sauce brings bold, fruity flavor to wings, pork, or even adventurous desserts. Hand-bottled and carefully packed, it’s a must-have for fans of indie horror and Peaches Christ.
    NC-17 Rated NC-17
  • Klowns R Us (5oz Waxed)

    Klowns R Us

    Klowns R Us is the official hot sauce of the 2026 Colorado Festival of Horror! This is our 3rd time making a sauce for COFOH, and as the theme for 2026 is Clowns Vs. Witches, we went and made this circus in a bottle! It hits with fruity sweetness up front and then quick heat after from the Carolina Reapers. Like clowns, this sauce is a little scary!

    Hover for more…
    Klowns R Us is the official hot sauce of the 2026 Colorado Festival of Horror! This is our 3rd time making a sauce for COFOH, and as the theme for 2026 is Clowns Vs. Witches, we went and made this circus in a bottle! It hits with fruity sweetness up front and then quick heat after from the Carolina Reapers. Like clowns, this sauce is a little scary!
    NC-17 Rated NC-17In stock
  • Linnea's Lipstick (Waxed)

    Linnea's Lipstick

    Linnea's Lipstick is the official hot sauce of scream queen Linnea Quigley! She wanted a watermelon and raspberry sauce that was REALLY HOT, and this NC-17 creation delivers. Using huge amounts of dehydrated watermelon, the flavor comes through immediately sweet and fruity, followed by an intense, building heat that lingers. Perfect for collectors and daring culinary enthusiasts, this sauce elevates chili, roasted meats, or any adventurous dish with a vibrant, cinematic punch.

    Hover for more…
    Linnea's Lipstick is the official hot sauce of scream queen Linnea Quigley! She wanted a watermelon and raspberry sauce that was REALLY HOT, and this NC-17 creation delivers. Using huge amounts of dehydrated watermelon, the flavor comes through immediately sweet and fruity, followed by an intense, building heat that lingers. Perfect for collectors and daring culinary enthusiasts, this sauce elevates chili, roasted meats, or any adventurous dish with a vibrant, cinematic punch.
    NC-17 Rated NC-17In stock
  • Matool's Hammer (5oz)

    Matool's Hammer

    Matool's Hammer is the official hot sauce of the movie The Stink of Flesh, available now on remastered Blu-Ray from Makeflix.com, in our store! This R-rated sauce blends New Mexican chiles with red and chocolate habaneros and reapers to create a deep, roasty heat that builds and lingers. Blackberries and black cherries add fruity complexity, while fresh and black garlic enhance the umami depth. Perfect for collectors or daring flavor adventurers, Matool's Hammer delivers cinematic heat for wings, enchiladas, or any dish needing a bold punch.

    Hover for more…
    Matool's Hammer is the official hot sauce of the movie The Stink of Flesh, available now on remastered Blu-Ray from Makeflix.com, in our store! This R-rated sauce blends New Mexican chiles with red and chocolate habaneros and reapers to create a deep, roasty heat that builds and lingers. Blackberries and black cherries add fruity complexity, while fresh and black garlic enhance the umami depth. Perfect for collectors or daring flavor adventurers, Matool's Hammer delivers cinematic heat for wings, enchiladas, or any dish needing a bold punch.
    R Rated RIn stock
  • Nightmare Sauce (5oz)

    Nightmare Sauce

    HORRID's Nightmare Sauce is the official hot sauce of HORRID, Denver’s Horror Store, created for fans who dare to taste the terror. A wicked blend of red jalapeño and habanero peppers, blood orange, and blackberries balances fruity sweetness with a creeping heat that will haunt your taste buds. Perfect on wings, tacos, or anything that needs a (small) nightmare-level kick, each bottle is hand-packed for collectors and horror aficionados alike.

    Hover for more…
    HORRID's Nightmare Sauce is the official hot sauce of HORRID, Denver’s Horror Store, created for fans who dare to taste the terror. A wicked blend of red jalapeño and habanero peppers, blood orange, and blackberries balances fruity sweetness with a creeping heat that will haunt your taste buds. Perfect on wings, tacos, or anything that needs a (small) nightmare-level kick, each bottle is hand-packed for collectors and horror aficionados alike.
    PG-13 Rated PG-13In stock
  • To Hell You Ride (5oz)

    To Hell You Ride

    To Hell You Ride is a version of The Burning, made exclusively as the official hot sauce of the Telluride Horror Show film festival. To Hell You Ride swaps out yellow manzaño for red manzaño (aka rocoto), leaving the sauce a much deeper reddish orange and ever so slightly spicier. The Burning is inspired by the 1980 cult classic of the same name. This PG-13 sauce layers mango, pineapple, and an intense mix of red jalapeño, manzaño, habanero, and ghost peppers. Starting with sweet tropical notes, it quickly develops a deep, lingering heat for those who dare. Perfect on grilled dishes, wings, or bold culinary experiments.

    Hover for more…
    To Hell You Ride is a version of The Burning, made exclusively as the official hot sauce of the Telluride Horror Show film festival. To Hell You Ride swaps out yellow manzaño for red manzaño (aka rocoto), leaving the sauce a much deeper reddish orange and ever so slightly spicier. The Burning is inspired by the 1980 cult classic of the same name. This PG-13 sauce layers mango, pineapple, and an intense mix of red jalapeño, manzaño, habanero, and ghost peppers. Starting with sweet tropical notes, it quickly develops a deep, lingering heat for those who dare. Perfect on grilled dishes, wings, or bold culinary experiments.
    PG-13 Rated PG-13In stock
  • Everyone's a Suspect

    Everyone's a Suspect

    Everyone's a Suspect is the official hot sauce of the 5th HORRIDfying Film Festival's feature, Screamwalkers. Crafted for those who crave intrigue alongside their heat. This tangy, complex sauce layers multiple varieties of Hatch Green Chile with citrus, fermented and roasted garlic, and a touch of sweetness from piloncillo sugar. Perfect on tacos, burgers, or any dish that could use a sneaky kick, it's a collector's dream and a conversation starter at any table.

    Hover for more…
    Everyone's a Suspect is the official hot sauce of the 5th HORRIDfying Film Festival's feature, Screamwalkers. Crafted for those who crave intrigue alongside their heat. This tangy, complex sauce layers multiple varieties of Hatch Green Chile with citrus, fermented and roasted garlic, and a touch of sweetness from piloncillo sugar. Perfect on tacos, burgers, or any dish that could use a sneaky kick, it's a collector's dream and a conversation starter at any table.
    PG-13 Rated PG-13
  • Game Over

    Game Over

    Game Over is the official hot sauce of the 2024 Colorado Festival of Horror. A touch of citrus and blueberry funk gives way to an intense heat that builds and lasts.

    Hover for more…
    Game Over is the official hot sauce of the 2024 Colorado Festival of Horror. A touch of citrus and blueberry funk gives way to an intense heat that builds and lasts.
    NC-17 Rated NC-17
  • National Bowling Tournament in Hawaii

    National Bowling Tournament in Hawaii

    National Bowling Tournament in Hawaii was created for the first HORRIDfying Film Festival's feature, Atom the Amazing Zombie Killer. It is an alternate version of our sauce The Burning, but with all the mango replaced with pineapple and the peppers amped up to a much hotter level.

    Hover for more…
    National Bowling Tournament in Hawaii was created for the first HORRIDfying Film Festival's feature, Atom the Amazing Zombie Killer. It is an alternate version of our sauce The Burning, but with all the mango replaced with pineapple and the peppers amped up to a much hotter level.
    NC-17 Rated NC-17
  • Somethin' Witchy

    Somethin' Witchy

    Somethin' Witchy was created for the 2nd HORRIDfying Film Festival's feature, Gimme Skelter. It is an alternate version of our sauce Matool's Hammer, but with cherries and the peppers amped up a much hotter level.

    Hover for more…
    Somethin' Witchy was created for the 2nd HORRIDfying Film Festival's feature, Gimme Skelter. It is an alternate version of our sauce Matool's Hammer, but with cherries and the peppers amped up a much hotter level.
    NC-17 Rated NC-17
  • Wolfman's…

    Wolfman's…

    Wolfman's… has both sweet & tart cherries, Barker's XXX Hot NM Chile, and a trinity of chocolate peppers: chocolate habaneros, scorpions, and reapers. This sauce also uses balsamic vinegar & red wine vinegar to add depth of flavor. Wolfman's… has a mildly hot sweet cherry kick up front which then builds over the next few minutes to a very hot experience. It's got nards.

    Hover for more…
    Wolfman's… has both sweet & tart cherries, Barker's XXX Hot NM Chile, and a trinity of chocolate peppers: chocolate habaneros, scorpions, and reapers. This sauce also uses balsamic vinegar & red wine vinegar to add depth of flavor. Wolfman's… has a mildly hot sweet cherry kick up front which then builds over the next few minutes to a very hot experience. It's got nards.
    NC-17 Rated NC-17

Seasonal & Special Sauces

  • Buffet for Sheetar (5oz)

    Buffet for Sheetar

    Buffet for Sheetar is a fiery homage to Blood Diner, blending wickedly hot peppers with dark, fruity undertones. This year-round sauce delivers a wicked punch that will thrill adventurous eaters. Drizzle it over tacos, wings, or roasted veggies, or dare to sample it straight from the bottle for a taste of chaos. Each bottle is hand-packed for collectors seeking flavor that’s as bold and memorable as a midnight cult classic.

    Hover for more…
    Buffet for Sheetar is a fiery homage to Blood Diner, blending wickedly hot peppers with dark, fruity undertones. This year-round sauce delivers a wicked punch that will thrill adventurous eaters. Drizzle it over tacos, wings, or roasted veggies, or dare to sample it straight from the bottle for a taste of chaos. Each bottle is hand-packed for collectors seeking flavor that’s as bold and memorable as a midnight cult classic.
    R Rated RIn stock
  • Monolith:Red (5oz)

    Monolith:Red

    Monolith:Red is one of two collaborations with Monolith Brewing in Denver, offering a hotter version of our Shutteracha. With artwork inspired by Hellraiser III, this PG-13 sauce blends red jalapeño, Xtra Hot Red New Mexico, guajillo, and habanero peppers for a smoky, spicy kick, balanced with fresh, powdered, and roasted garlic, piloncillo sugar, lime juice, and rice wine vinegar. Perfect for wings, sandwiches, or adventurous culinary creations, this sauce delivers bold flavor with a cinematic edge.

    Hover for more…
    Monolith:Red is one of two collaborations with Monolith Brewing in Denver, offering a hotter version of our Shutteracha. With artwork inspired by Hellraiser III, this PG-13 sauce blends red jalapeño, Xtra Hot Red New Mexico, guajillo, and habanero peppers for a smoky, spicy kick, balanced with fresh, powdered, and roasted garlic, piloncillo sugar, lime juice, and rice wine vinegar. Perfect for wings, sandwiches, or adventurous culinary creations, this sauce delivers bold flavor with a cinematic edge.
    PG-13 Rated PG-13In stock
  • Season of the Witch (5oz)

    Season of the Witch

    Season of the Witch draws inspiration from classic supernatural horror and its awesome masks (Pumpkin Mask © Trick or Treat Studios, used with kind permission) as well as a perennial fall favorite: the PSL! This R-rated sauce blends red jalapeño, chocolate habanero, orange bell, and Carolina Reaper peppers with pumpkin, carrot, and pumpkin pie spices offering a spicy-sweet complexity. Finished with piloncillo sugar and warming spices, it’s perfect for adventurous palates on roasted dishes, stews, or creatively daring recipes. Rated R Ingredients: Peppers (Red Jalapeño, Chocolate Habanero, Orange Bell, Carolina Reaper), Pumpkin, Carrot, Brine (Filtered Water, Salt), Apple Cider Vinegar, Piloncillo Sugar, Spices (Ground Cloves, Ancho Chile, Ginger, Cinnamon, Star Anise) Pure Vanilla Extract (Vanilla beans, alcohol)

    Hover for more…
    Season of the Witch draws inspiration from classic supernatural horror and its awesome masks (Pumpkin Mask © Trick or Treat Studios, used with kind permission) as well as a perennial fall favorite: the PSL! This R-rated sauce blends red jalapeño, chocolate habanero, orange bell, and Carolina Reaper peppers with pumpkin, carrot, and pumpkin pie spices offering a spicy-sweet complexity. Finished with piloncillo sugar and warming spices, it’s perfect for adventurous palates on roasted dishes, stews, or creatively daring recipes. Rated R Ingredients: Peppers (Red Jalapeño, Chocolate Habanero, Orange Bell, Carolina Reaper), Pumpkin, Carrot, Brine (Filtered Water, Salt), Apple Cider Vinegar, Piloncillo Sugar, Spices (Ground Cloves, Ancho Chile, Ginger, Cinnamon, Star Anise) Pure Vanilla Extract (Vanilla beans, alcohol)
    R Rated RIn stock
  • Sweets for the Sweet (5oz)

    Sweets for the Sweet

    Sweets for the Sweet, formerly known as Black is Beautiful, is a darkly fruity R-rated sauce inspired by Candyman and paying tribute to black horror in general. This bold sauce blends red jalapeño, chocolate habanero, and ghost peppers with black cherries, blackberries, and black garlic for a rich, complex flavor. A touch of stout beer in the brine and a combination of rice and white wine vinegars balances the intense heat and deep fruitiness, making it perfect for adventurous eaters or collectors seeking a cinematic horror-inspired experience.

    Hover for more…
    Sweets for the Sweet, formerly known as Black is Beautiful, is a darkly fruity R-rated sauce inspired by Candyman and paying tribute to black horror in general. This bold sauce blends red jalapeño, chocolate habanero, and ghost peppers with black cherries, blackberries, and black garlic for a rich, complex flavor. A touch of stout beer in the brine and a combination of rice and white wine vinegars balances the intense heat and deep fruitiness, making it perfect for adventurous eaters or collectors seeking a cinematic horror-inspired experience.
    R Rated RIn stock
  • Dawn of the Citrus (5oz Waxed)

    Dawn of the Citrus

    Dawn of the Citrus is HHS' 3rd Anniversary Sauce, and is ONE BATCH ONLY (~55 bottles total). When it’s gone, it’s GONE, and it’s not coming back! For the 3rd anniversary of HHS, we made a sauce filled with weird and wild peppers including KSPS, All Hallow’s Eve, Sharknado Outbreak, and red and yellow Carolina Reapers! This is added to a base of pineapple and citrus including oranges, mandarins, yuzu, blood oranges, and lemons, and even more pure yuzu juice in the blend. This sauce screams citrus and heat, it could wake the dead!

    Hover for more…
    Dawn of the Citrus is HHS' 3rd Anniversary Sauce, and is ONE BATCH ONLY (~55 bottles total). When it’s gone, it’s GONE, and it’s not coming back! For the 3rd anniversary of HHS, we made a sauce filled with weird and wild peppers including KSPS, All Hallow’s Eve, Sharknado Outbreak, and red and yellow Carolina Reapers! This is added to a base of pineapple and citrus including oranges, mandarins, yuzu, blood oranges, and lemons, and even more pure yuzu juice in the blend. This sauce screams citrus and heat, it could wake the dead!
    NC-17 Rated NC-17In stock
  • Blood Punch

    Blood Punch

    Blood Punch is a sauce crafted around the Schomber Blood Punch pepper, created by Mike Schomber of M&C's Peppers. In addition to the Blood Punch, this sauce is also made from Scorpion peppers grown by Mike. Blood Punch is also a fruit punch sauce, and utilizes many of the fruit included in traditional Hawaiian punch recipes.

    Hover for more…
    Blood Punch is a sauce crafted around the Schomber Blood Punch pepper, created by Mike Schomber of M&C's Peppers. In addition to the Blood Punch, this sauce is also made from Scorpion peppers grown by Mike. Blood Punch is also a fruit punch sauce, and utilizes many of the fruit included in traditional Hawaiian punch recipes.
    NC-17 Rated NC-17
  • Dellamorte

    Dellamorte

    Our attempt to bottle the flavor of fresh reapers. It starts floral and then quickly escalates to intense heat.

    Hover for more…
    Our attempt to bottle the flavor of fresh reapers. It starts floral and then quickly escalates to intense heat.
    NC-17 Rated NC-17
  • Monolith:Yellow

    Monolith:Yellow

    Our second collaboration with Monolith Brewing in Denver, this is a hotter version of MoMo, with the addition of lemons and habanero peppers to give it a kick!

    Hover for more…
    Our second collaboration with Monolith Brewing in Denver, this is a hotter version of MoMo, with the addition of lemons and habanero peppers to give it a kick!
    PG-13 Rated PG-13
  • OMFG!!!!!!!

    OMFG!!!!!!!

    OMFG!!!!!!! is an amped-up version of our verde sauce, OMG!!!!!!!. All of the jalapeños from the original recipe have been replaced with habaneros, and added are yellow habanero and the uncommon but awesomely flavored KSLS pepper. This one hits hard relatively quickly and then slowly fades.

    Hover for more…
    OMFG!!!!!!! is an amped-up version of our verde sauce, OMG!!!!!!!. All of the jalapeños from the original recipe have been replaced with habaneros, and added are yellow habanero and the uncommon but awesomely flavored KSLS pepper. This one hits hard relatively quickly and then slowly fades.
    NC-17 Rated NC-17
  • The Color Out of Space

    The Color Out of Space

    (v2) A combination of fresh peach/purple peppers, açai, prickly pear, and fermented brine from Pazuzu. This sauce will be made with different peppers and modifications to the fruit each time it is made.

    Hover for more…
    (v2) A combination of fresh peach/purple peppers, açai, prickly pear, and fermented brine from Pazuzu. This sauce will be made with different peppers and modifications to the fruit each time it is made.
    NC-17 Rated NC-17

Archived or Retired Sauces

  • 3 Tears

    3 Tears

    A collaboration with filmmaker Jakob Bilinski for his film Three Tears on Bloodstained Flesh.

    Hover for more…
    A collaboration with filmmaker Jakob Bilinski for his film Three Tears on Bloodstained Flesh.
    R Rated RRetired
  • Ain't Afraid

    Ain't Afraid

    Ain't Afraid is HHS' one-time 1st Anniversary Sauce. It is made with a huge variety of ghostly white peppers (jicama, dragonfruit, and lychee). It's a white hot sauce that will haunt your nightmares. Are you afraid?

    Hover for more…
    Ain't Afraid is HHS' one-time 1st Anniversary Sauce. It is made with a huge variety of ghostly white peppers (jicama, dragonfruit, and lychee). It's a white hot sauce that will haunt your nightmares. Are you afraid?
    NC-17 Rated NC-17Retired
  • Alpha-21

    Alpha-21

    Alpha-21 is a collaboration with filmmaker J.R. Bookwalter for his film Side Effects May Vary, an icky-sticky social satire that substitutes the "Atomic Hysteria" of the 50's with the modern pandemic, and fills it with plenty of oozy gore. This sauce is an extra hot version of our verde sauce, OMG!!!!!!!, and has additional yellow habanero and yellow ghost peppers on top of that base.

    Hover for more…
    Alpha-21 is a collaboration with filmmaker J.R. Bookwalter for his film Side Effects May Vary, an icky-sticky social satire that substitutes the "Atomic Hysteria" of the 50's with the modern pandemic, and fills it with plenty of oozy gore. This sauce is an extra hot version of our verde sauce, OMG!!!!!!!, and has additional yellow habanero and yellow ghost peppers on top of that base.
    R Rated RRetired
  • Black is Beautiful

    Black is Beautiful

    A collaboration Weathered Souls Brewing Company. Remade as Sweets for the Sweet.

    Hover for more…
    A collaboration Weathered Souls Brewing Company. Remade as Sweets for the Sweet.
    R Rated RRetired
  • Original Sin

    Original Sin

    A sauce made from apples and manzaño peppers.

    Hover for more…
    A sauce made from apples and manzaño peppers.
    PG Rated PGRetired
  • Paimon & Hårga
    Paimon & Hårga

    Paimon & Hårga

    A 2-part tribute to filmmaker Ari Aster. Paimon is dark while Hårga is bright and sunny.

    Hover for more…
    A 2-part tribute to filmmaker Ari Aster. Paimon is dark while Hårga is bright and sunny.
    R Rated RRetired
  • The Resonator

    The Resonator

    The Resonator is Horrifying Hot Sauce's 2nd Anniversary Sauce, a NC-17 powerhouse inspired by From Beyond. This one-batch-only collector's sauce blends a vast array of peppers — including habanero, ghost, KSLS, ají amarillo, and multiple reaper varieties — with prickly pear, black plum, dragonfruit, and citrus for a complex, lingering heat and rich fruity undertones. Perfect for collectors or daring culinary creators looking to experience extreme flavor.

    Hover for more…
    The Resonator is Horrifying Hot Sauce's 2nd Anniversary Sauce, a NC-17 powerhouse inspired by From Beyond. This one-batch-only collector's sauce blends a vast array of peppers — including habanero, ghost, KSLS, ají amarillo, and multiple reaper varieties — with prickly pear, black plum, dragonfruit, and citrus for a complex, lingering heat and rich fruity undertones. Perfect for collectors or daring culinary creators looking to experience extreme flavor.
    NC-17 Rated NC-17Retired
  • Voodoo

    Voodoo

    A combination of tropical ingredients brings a medium, fruity heat.

    Hover for more…
    A combination of tropical ingredients brings a medium, fruity heat.
    PG-13 Rated PG-13Retired