Fermented, small-batch, hand made

All sauces are made by hand, in 3 Gallon ferments. 50-100 bottles per batch.

All natural: no emulsifiers, preservatives, extracts, or additives

Yes the color may fade over time but the flavor won't, and we prefer to not have extra STUFF added!

All original horror artwork — no AI!

All art painted by hand on Procreate.
We will NEVER use AI art!
NEVER!!!

Dawn of the Citrus (5oz Waxed)
FEATURED SAUCE

Dawn of the Citrus

The hottest day of horror the world has known!

Help! Alive Inside!!

Dawn of the Citrus is HHS' 3rd Anniversary Sauce, and is ONE BATCH ONLY (~55 bottles total). When it’s gone, it’s GONE, and it’s not coming back! For the 3rd anniversary of HHS, we made a sauce filled with weird and wild peppers including KSPS, All Hallow’s Eve, Sharknado Outbreak, and red and yellow Carolina Reapers! This is added to a base of pineapple and citrus including oranges, mandarins, yuzu, blood oranges, and lemons, and even more pure yuzu juice in the blend. This sauce screams citrus and heat, it...

NC-17 Really Hot!!!5 oz · $19.99

Critics Rave

Read all reviews →

Now Showing

Pazuzu (5oz)

Pazuzu

The power compels you, but will it be enough?

Pazuzu is a slow-building R-rated sauce that balances the fruity sweetness of watermelon and prickly pear with sweet-tart blueberries and punchy heat from Habanero, with some Ghost and Carolina Reaper peppers to make the heat linger. The combination teases the tongue before launching a fiery crescendo, making it a must-try for heat adventurers and horror enthusiasts alike. Plus, it's purple!

Hover for more…
Pazuzu is a slow-building R-rated sauce that balances the fruity sweetness of watermelon and prickly pear with sweet-tart blueberries and punchy heat from Habanero, with some Ghost and Carolina Reaper peppers to make the heat linger. The combination teases the tongue before launching a fiery crescendo, making it a must-try for heat adventurers and horror enthusiasts alike. Plus, it's purple!
R Hot5 oz · $12.99
MoMo (5oz)

MoMo

She's sweet… until she's not!

MoMo is a creepy, playful sauce inspired by the mysterious pairing of mango and manzano peppers — hence the name. With sweet, fruity mango notes, tangy vinegar, and a sneaky, lingering manzano heat, this small-batch sauce is perfect for daring flavor explorers. Use it on chicken, eggs, or anything that needs a tropical kick with a hint of menace. Hand-packed and carefully bottled, MoMo is a cult favorite for collectors seeking unusual, memorable flavor.

Hover for more…
MoMo is a creepy, playful sauce inspired by the mysterious pairing of mango and manzano peppers — hence the name. With sweet, fruity mango notes, tangy vinegar, and a sneaky, lingering manzano heat, this small-batch sauce is perfect for daring flavor explorers. Use it on chicken, eggs, or anything that needs a tropical kick with a hint of menace. Hand-packed and carefully bottled, MoMo is a cult favorite for collectors seeking unusual, memorable flavor.
PG Mild5 oz · $12.99
Linnea's Lipstick (Waxed)

Linnea's Lipstick

This lipstick might just scar you for life!

Linnea's Lipstick is the official hot sauce of scream queen Linnea Quigley! She wanted a watermelon and raspberry sauce that was REALLY HOT, and this NC-17 creation delivers. Using huge amounts of dehydrated watermelon, the flavor comes through immediately sweet and fruity, followed by an intense, building heat that lingers. Perfect for collectors and daring culinary enthusiasts, this sauce elevates chili, roasted meats, or any adventurous dish with a vibrant, cinematic punch.

Hover for more…
Linnea's Lipstick is the official hot sauce of scream queen Linnea Quigley! She wanted a watermelon and raspberry sauce that was REALLY HOT, and this NC-17 creation delivers. Using huge amounts of dehydrated watermelon, the flavor comes through immediately sweet and fruity, followed by an intense, building heat that lingers. Perfect for collectors and daring culinary enthusiasts, this sauce elevates chili, roasted meats, or any adventurous dish with a vibrant, cinematic punch.
Official sauce of Linnea Quigley
NC-17 Really Hot!!!5 oz · $17.99
Dawn of the Citrus (5oz Waxed)

Dawn of the Citrus

Help! Alive Inside!!

Dawn of the Citrus is HHS' 3rd Anniversary Sauce, and is ONE BATCH ONLY (~55 bottles total). When it’s gone, it’s GONE, and it’s not coming back! For the 3rd anniversary of HHS, we made a sauce filled with weird and wild peppers including KSPS, All Hallow’s Eve, Sharknado Outbreak, and red and yellow Carolina Reapers! This is added to a base of pineapple and citrus including oranges, mandarins, yuzu, blood oranges, and lemons, and even more pure yuzu juice in the blend. This sauce screams citrus and heat, it...

Hover for more…
Dawn of the Citrus is HHS' 3rd Anniversary Sauce, and is ONE BATCH ONLY (~55 bottles total). When it’s gone, it’s GONE, and it’s not coming back! For the 3rd anniversary of HHS, we made a sauce filled with weird and wild peppers including KSPS, All Hallow’s Eve, Sharknado Outbreak, and red and yellow Carolina Reapers! This is added to a base of pineapple and citrus including oranges, mandarins, yuzu, blood oranges, and lemons, and even more pure yuzu juice in the blend. This sauce screams citrus and heat, it...
NC-17 Really Hot!!!5 oz · $19.99
Matool's Hammer (5oz)

Matool's Hammer

Roasty. Relentless. Like a zombie shuffling across the mesa.

Matool's Hammer is the official hot sauce of the movie The Stink of Flesh, available now on remastered Blu-Ray from Makeflix.com, in our store! This R-rated sauce blends New Mexican chiles with red and chocolate habaneros and reapers to create a deep, roasty heat that builds and lingers. Blackberries and black cherries add fruity complexity, while fresh and black garlic enhance the umami depth. Perfect for collectors or daring flavor adventurers, Matool's Hammer delivers cinematic heat for wings, enchiladas, or any dish needing a bold punch.

Hover for more…
Matool's Hammer is the official hot sauce of the movie The Stink of Flesh, available now on remastered Blu-Ray from Makeflix.com, in our store! This R-rated sauce blends New Mexican chiles with red and chocolate habaneros and reapers to create a deep, roasty heat that builds and lingers. Blackberries and black cherries add fruity complexity, while fresh and black garlic enhance the umami depth. Perfect for collectors or daring flavor adventurers, Matool's Hammer delivers cinematic heat for wings, enchiladas, or any dish needing a bold punch.
Official sauce of The Stink of Flesh
R Hot5 oz · $12.99
Season of the Witch (5oz)

Season of the Witch

Halloween, halloween, a few more days ’til Halloween… and when the season is over, it’s gone until next year.

Season of the Witch draws inspiration from classic supernatural horror and its awesome masks (Pumpkin Mask © Trick or Treat Studios, used with kind permission) as well as a perennial fall favorite: the PSL! This R-rated sauce blends red jalapeño, chocolate habanero, orange bell, and Carolina Reaper peppers with pumpkin, carrot, and pumpkin pie spices offering a spicy-sweet complexity. Finished with piloncillo sugar and warming spices, it’s perfect for adventurous palates on roasted dishes, stews, or creatively daring recipes. Rated R Ingredients: Peppers (Red Jalapeño, Chocolate Habanero, Orange Bell, Carolina Reaper),...

Hover for more…
Season of the Witch draws inspiration from classic supernatural horror and its awesome masks (Pumpkin Mask © Trick or Treat Studios, used with kind permission) as well as a perennial fall favorite: the PSL! This R-rated sauce blends red jalapeño, chocolate habanero, orange bell, and Carolina Reaper peppers with pumpkin, carrot, and pumpkin pie spices offering a spicy-sweet complexity. Finished with piloncillo sugar and warming spices, it’s perfect for adventurous palates on roasted dishes, stews, or creatively daring recipes. Rated R Ingredients: Peppers (Red Jalapeño, Chocolate Habanero, Orange Bell, Carolina Reaper),...
R Hot5 oz · $12.99
Buffet for Sheetar (5oz)

Buffet for Sheetar

The feast has begun... are YOU on the menu?

Buffet for Sheetar is a fiery homage to Blood Diner, blending wickedly hot peppers with dark, fruity undertones. This year-round sauce delivers a wicked punch that will thrill adventurous eaters. Drizzle it over tacos, wings, or roasted veggies, or dare to sample it straight from the bottle for a taste of chaos. Each bottle is hand-packed for collectors seeking flavor that’s as bold and memorable as a midnight cult classic.

Hover for more…
Buffet for Sheetar is a fiery homage to Blood Diner, blending wickedly hot peppers with dark, fruity undertones. This year-round sauce delivers a wicked punch that will thrill adventurous eaters. Drizzle it over tacos, wings, or roasted veggies, or dare to sample it straight from the bottle for a taste of chaos. Each bottle is hand-packed for collectors seeking flavor that’s as bold and memorable as a midnight cult classic.
R Hot5 oz · $12.99
To Hell You Ride (5oz)

To Hell You Ride

Buy the ticket, take the ride... but it might just be your last.

To Hell You Ride is a version of The Burning, made exclusively as the official hot sauce of the Telluride Horror Show film festival. To Hell You Ride swaps out yellow manzaño for red manzaño (aka rocoto), leaving the sauce a much deeper reddish orange and ever so slightly spicier. The Burning is inspired by the 1980 cult classic of the same name. This PG-13 sauce layers mango, pineapple, and an intense mix of red jalapeño, manzaño, habanero, and ghost peppers. Starting with sweet tropical notes, it quickly develops a...

Hover for more…
To Hell You Ride is a version of The Burning, made exclusively as the official hot sauce of the Telluride Horror Show film festival. To Hell You Ride swaps out yellow manzaño for red manzaño (aka rocoto), leaving the sauce a much deeper reddish orange and ever so slightly spicier. The Burning is inspired by the 1980 cult classic of the same name. This PG-13 sauce layers mango, pineapple, and an intense mix of red jalapeño, manzaño, habanero, and ghost peppers. Starting with sweet tropical notes, it quickly develops a...
Official sauce of The Telluride Horror Show
PG-13 Medium5 oz · $12.99

Matinee Specials

  • 10off4 10% off any 4 or more bottles of sauce
  • 15off6 15% off any 6 or more bottles of sauce
  • FREE SHIPPING on every order of $120 or more

Enter the code at checkout · Free shipping applies automatically

Looking for Something?

If you are interested in a sauce or sauces that are out of stock, add them here and we will email you when they are back!

    Coming Soon

    Sold Out

    Official Sauce Of…

    Scream Queens

    Movies

    Festivals

    • The 2024 Colorado Festival of HorrorGame Over
    • The 2025 Colorado Festival of HorrorWolfman's…
    • The 2026 Colorado Festival of HorrorKlowns R Us
    • The Telluride Horror ShowTo Hell You Ride

    Friends of HHS

    • HORRID, Denver's Horror StoreNightmare Sauce